ClearLine Forensics

Case Study

Roof Deterioration Damage

Distinguishing storm damage from pre-existing deterioration on a residential roof through forensic material analysis and historical evidence review.

Background

A homeowner reported wind-related damage following a recent storm. The team was retained to inspect the roof covering and surrounding property features to determine whether reported issues were storm-related and recent, or the result of pre-existing conditions.


Investigation

A comprehensive roof inspection was performed, focusing on the condition of asphalt shingles, underlying felt, and decking.

Observed damage patterns were compared against weather data and historical satellite imagery to evaluate the age and progression of the roof’s condition.


Key Findings

Observed Damage

Numerous asphalt shingles were torn, uplifted, or missing entirely. In several areas, large patches of shingles were absent, leaving plywood decking exposed.

Material Condition

Felt paper beneath damaged sections was heavily oxidized and coated with debris, indicating long-term exposure. Plywood substrate was severely weathered from extended sun exposure.

Historical Evidence

Available satellite imagery confirmed significant roof damage predated the most recent storm event.

Contributing Factors

Poor roof covering performance and/or inadequate attic ventilation likely compromised shingle adhesion, making the roof susceptible to gradual uplift and deterioration.

Outcome

The investigation determined the damage was primarily the result of long-term deterioration and deferred maintenance, not the recent storm event. While some minor wind damage may have occurred, the majority of the observed conditions predated the storm.

Takeaways

Distinguishing between storm-induced damage and pre-existing deterioration requires careful material analysis and correlation with historical data.

Satellite imagery and weather records are valuable tools for establishing the timeline of roof damage.

Need a Similar Investigation?

Our licensed engineers and certified investigators are ready to help with your case.